The Ridiculous Error Rates Of The Monthly New Jobs Reports
From Tampa Free Press
Article By Justin Weller, Original Publish Date: April 5, 2024
This morning, another positive jobs report came out from the BLS. They’ve reported 303,000 new jobs created in March, the highest initial report since September. Unemployment also went down a tick to 3.8%. The CNBC crowd is doing cartwheels this morning and every one is touting a great economy.
For a while, I’ve been flummoxed by the reports and the seemingly consistent revisions downward as the BLS adjusts their reports, issuing a first and then second revision for each month subsequently. In other words, in this March report they also revise the figures from February and January and do so each time.
This morning I decided to get to the bottom of the change in jobs numbers from those revisions. I went to the BLS site and searched each month to find the initial figures reported and the subsequent second revision for each month from February 2023 to January 2024 (the last month for which we have the second revision numbers currently). The results are shocking:
The BLS revises its own figures to the tune of anywhere from an 8.5% to 50% error rate within two months. And almost always downward.
There is therefore very little value to the initial reporting of new jobs created, nor the expectations set by Wall Street before the report. Yet invariably the new report and its comparison to expectations become breathless headlines. For example, Business Insider writes this morning, “the latest jobs report is the Fed’s holy grail: strong job market with non-inflationary growth.”
But here’s what the error rate for Wall St’s expectations look like:
So, the expectations from Wall Street for the monthly jobs report are almost always lower that the report and have an error rate as high as 100%; likewise, the BLS’ own initial new jobs report has an error rate as high as 50%.
And yet, each month all major news outlets and political types flail wildly back and forth with their predictions, analyses and reactions to wildly inaccurate data that has little relation to reality. It’s the silliest game going. Don’t believe a word of it.
Justin Weller is a lifelong political junkie and founder of The Country. His Friday columns are republished here at the Tampa Free Press. To get access all of the content at The Country, please subscribe here.
The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of the Tampa Free Press.
TAMPA FREE PRESS
Android Users, Click To Download The Free Press App And Never Miss A Story. Follow Us On Facebook and Twitter. Signup for our free newsletter.
We can’t do this without your help; visit our GiveSendGo page and donate any dollar amount; every penny helps.