$800K California Investment Can’t Fast-Track A Green Card, Federal Judge Rules

A federal court cannot force immigration officials to speed up decisions on an investor visa and green card application, a federal judge in Washington ruled Monday.

U.S. District Judge Trevor N. McFadden dismissed a lawsuit filed by Manoj Patrick John Bosco Rayan, an Indian national who sued federal officials after waiting more than 17 months without an answer on his EB-5 immigrant investor filings. McFadden concluded that provisions in the Immigration and Nationality Act prevent federal district courts from hearing lawsuits that challenge the pace of those administrative reviews.

Rayan filed an I-526E investor petition and an I-485 application for permanent residence in late September 2024. According to court filings, he put more than $800,000 into an enterprise meant to “finance the development and operation of a portfolio of affiliated housing projects located throughout the San Francisco and East Bay area.”

The federal EB-5 program allows foreign citizens to apply for permanent residence if they invest significant capital in commercial ventures that create at least 10 full-time American jobs. General investments require at least $1,050,000, while projects in targeted employment areas or infrastructure efforts require at least $800,000.

 

After more than 17 months passed without word from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, Rayan brought a lawsuit under the Administrative Procedure Act and the Mandamus Act against the Secretary of Homeland Security Mullin, the director of USCIS, and the chief of the Immigrant Investor Program Office. He asked the court to compel the agencies to quickly adjudicate his paperwork.

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin

The government moved to dismiss the complaint, arguing the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction under federal immigration statutes. Rayan opposed the motion and asked the judge for summary judgment, pointing to language in the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022. Rayan argued that provisions aiming for average 240-day processing timelines created an enforceable requirement that overrode agency discretion.

McFadden rejected that argument, stating that the statutory reference to 240 days was part of a study on fee structures and reflected an average target rather than a strict legal deadline for individual cases. The judge noted that federal law explicitly allows the Department of Homeland Security to process investor petitions “in a manner and order established by the Secretary,” while adjustment-of-status applications are handled entirely within executive discretion.

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act’s jurisdictional rules, federal courts are barred from reviewing discretionary decisions and actions made by immigration authorities. McFadden wrote that this restriction covers not just the final decision on an application, but the speed and process of reaching it.

“The long immigrant visa queue imposes significant hardship,” McFadden wrote, adding that he understood the plaintiff’s frustration. However, he noted that the court could not let practical hardships override federal law, writing that “policy concerns cannot trump the best interpretation of the statutory text.”

Because the court found it had no jurisdiction under the statute, McFadden dismissed Rayan’s lawsuit and denied his motion for summary judgment.